Ofsted has published a report entitled No place for...
- Education Professionals
State school pupils face unfair fight for university places
The Sutton Trust is urging Ucas, which administers university entries, to revise the system, arguing that private school students not only tend to submit more carefully-crafted statements but generally have a more privileged set of experiences about which to boast such as work experience at blue chip employers.
The recommendation comes in a study by Steven Jones, an education lecturer at Manchester University, who studied more than 300 personal statements submitted to the same department of a leading university by students with the same A-level results.
As an example of the sorts of disparities visible, the report cites one private school pupil who recounts work experience for a designer in London, on the trading floor of a financial broker, at a BBC radio station and in a City law firm, contrasting this with a state student who discusses a school trip to Cadbury World.
Of the sample of applicants, the study found that 70% of the private pupils were offered places, compared with 50% of those from state school and sixth form colleges.
The trust says the system could be made fairer by asking applicants to describe what talents and attributes they would bring rather than describing prior achievements, with a limit on the number of experiences listed. State schools could offer better support in helping pupils with statements while admissions tutors could take more account of an applicants' social background.
Sir Peter Lampl, chair of the Sutton Trust, said good state institutions already offered pupils proper help "but admissions processes also need to change".